Published August 2026
Three parties, three different jobs
Every Gold IRA has to clear the same legal hurdle every IRA does: under IRC §408(a), the account must be held by a qualified trustee or custodian, not by the account owner directly. IRC §408(a)(2) narrows who qualifies — a bank, a federally or state-chartered credit union, or a non-bank entity that has specifically applied for and received IRS approval to act as a trustee. That approval process is not automatic and not the same thing as being licensed to sell gold. A precious metals dealer’s marketing website and a custodian’s IRS non-bank trustee approval are two entirely different things, and only one of them is legally required to hold your account.
The dealer’s job is narrower than it sounds from most sales pitches: source and sell you IRS-eligible coins or bars (99.5% pure gold, with a specific carve-out for the American Gold Eagle, under IRC §408(m)(3)). The custodian’s job is to hold legal title to the IRA, execute the purchase and storage instructions, and file the IRS reporting (Form 5498 for contributions, Form 1099-R for distributions). The depository’s job is physical security — an IRS-approved, insured vault, segregated or commingled depending on what you paid for. None of the three is optional, and none of them substitutes for the other two.
Who does what
| Party | Actual role | Who’s legally allowed to do it |
|---|---|---|
| Dealer | Sources and sells the physical coins/bars | Any precious metals business — no special IRA license required to sell metal itself |
| Custodian/Trustee | Holds legal title, executes transactions, handles IRS reporting | Bank, credit union, or IRS-approved non-bank trustee only (IRC §408(a)(2)) |
| Depository | Physically stores and insures the metal | IRS-approved depository under the custodian’s control (IRC §408(m) physical-possession rule) |
Role definitions per IRC §408(a)(2) (trustee eligibility) and §408(m) (precious metals custody and fineness rules); structure confirmed against how gold IRA custodian, dealer, and depository relationships are described in current industry and CPA-firm guidance.
The red flag worth knowing
If a company tells you it will personally hold your IRA’s gold, or that you don’t need a separate custodian because “we handle everything,” ask directly whether they are the IRS-approved trustee of record or whether they’re referring you to one. A legitimate dealer will name the actual custodian and depository being used and won’t be evasive about the difference — because the difference is a legal requirement, not a sales preference.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the dealer I buy gold from also be my custodian?
Only if that dealer separately holds IRS non-bank trustee approval under IRC §408(a)(2) — being a metals dealer alone does not qualify a company to act as your IRA’s custodian.
Do I get to pick my own depository?
Usually yes, from a list your custodian works with. The depository must be IRS-approved and the metal must remain in the custodian’s control — you cannot take personal physical possession of IRA-owned metal without triggering a distribution.
Why does this three-party structure exist at all?
It’s the mechanism Congress and the IRS use to allow a narrow exception (physical precious metals) to the general rule that IRAs can’t hold collectibles — the custodian and depository requirements are what keep the arrangement compliant with IRC §408(m).
0 Comments